Deceptive Lawmakers Trying To Sneak Flavor Bans In New York
Lawmakers are in the process of banning e-liquid flavors, yet there hasn’t been much coverage so far
Vaping flavor bans are becoming an all too common part of being a vaper in America. As the latest trend from lawmakers looking to demonize the alternative to cigarettes, e-liquid flavor bans have started popping up all over. Most recently San Francisco voted to implement the nation’s strictest flavor ban with nearly 70% of citizens voting in favor of the ban. Unfortunately, it seems that this problem will get worse before it starts to get better.
Now an entire state is considering a wide-spread and comprehensive e-liquid flavor ban. Although it has received almost no coverage from major media outlets so far, this new battle could prove extremely pivotal in the future of vaping. It should come as no surprise that this fight for vaping rights will take place across New York State. The proposed bill still has significant hurdles to overcome, but it already passed its first big test, the state Assembly.
The Potential Ban
The bill introduced in New York State would immediately put into effect a ban on flavored e-liquids. It has already passed through the Assembly and now waits its turn in the Senate. The bill claims that e-liquid flavors and colored packaging are aimed to “lure young people at their most vulnerable age.” The bill also claims that young people are lured by a “perceived lower risk.” The bill’s ultimate goal is to “eliminate the temptation for young people in New York State to try flavored electronic cigarettes and in turn reduce the number of people who become regular users of tobacco products.” Perhaps unsurprisingly, the bill’s author is so misinformed on vaping they claim the ban, which would likely shut down countless small vape shops, would have no fiscal implications at all.
This Bill (S8610) is clearly and heavily influenced by the wave of misinformation about vaping that is penetrating the media and causing unwarranted panic among parents. The author of this bill appears to be under the same belief as nearly a third of the population, that vaping is just as dangerous as smoking. Misinformation and hyperbolic views are rampant throughout the bill, and none of the scientific research on vaping that is readily available was cited. Let’s take a closer look at just how ridiculous parts of this bill get.
When you take a look at the proposed bill, it doesn’t take long before you start to find some serious issues. First of all, the bill claims that vaping poses a significant risk to teens, but then only uses studies on teenage smoking to back that up. It also claims that flavors aren’t integral to their harm reduction and smoking cessation utility, but studies have shown that flavors significantly increase the likelihood a smoker quits for good. If that wasn’t enough, a recent survey found that vaping bans are actually doing more harm than good. The Yale University report concluded that vaping bans ultimately increase the number of teenage smokers, as opposed to curbing the rate.
Another section of the bill proposal states that teens may be more likely to pick up vaporizers due to a “perceived lower risk,” which they imply is false. The problem is that there is a growing mountain of evidence proving that not only is vaping safer than smoking, but it’s at least 95% safer than cigarettes. Lastly, and possibly most importantly, the legislators somehow estimated that a flavor ban across NYS would have no fiscal implications for the state whatsoever. This is patently false to anyone who has seen what similar bans and taxes have done to the vaping industry within a state. The truth is that around $70 million in tax revenue alone is brought into the state thanks to the vaping sector every year. Money that would be sorely missed if it was significantly reduced.
NYS in many ways sets an example for other states with the bills they pass. Because of this, if the bill isn’t stopped not only would the independent vaping industry take a massive hit, but it could plausibly just be the first domino to fall. If NYS sets a precedent, many other states are libel to follow as the narrative becomes about groupthink over rational decision making.
With this in mind, NYSVA (the New York State Vapor Association), an advocacy group that’s been fighting for vaping rights in New York for years, is asking residents to write their senators. Explain to them precisely what vaping has done for you. Mention the numerous peer-reviewed articles that clearly indicate vaping is much safer than smoking. Above all else, make sure your voice is heard so we can protect the flavors that have helped countless smokers finally quit smoking combustible cigarettes.
Are you surprised that New York is attempting to sneak this ban through? Why do you think it’s so easy to demonize vaping in regards to regulations? How can we prove that vaping should be supported for its harm reduction and smoking cessation value? Let us know what you think in the comments, and don’t forget to check back here or join our Facebook and Twitter communities for more news and articles.